Innovate
The Ones Who Can Still Decide
— CO-AUTHORED By George Jackus, Abey Abraham & Chris Finch
Sometime over the last two years, meetings started happening in organizations everywhere. Someone senior looks around the table and says some version of the same thing: We need to get better at AI (artificial intelligence). People in the room nod knowingly. Action items get assigned out. More training. Better prompts. Faster outputs.
Nobody stops to consider whether getting faster is actually the right thing to do.
Every major economic shift follows the same general pattern. Something that used to be scarce stops being scarce. The people and societies who built their value around it keep doing what they’ve always done; they just do it harder. And while they’re doing that, the economy revalues everything.
It’s been a long time since I sat in a history class by my take is that we have been through this three times. In the early stages of human society, agriculture rewarded physical output. Then, in the 19th century the Industrial Revolution changed the game and manufacturing rewarded production capacity. Over the last 75 years or so, we’ve transitioned to an information economy where knowledge is prized. The person who knows more, can synthesize faster and communicates it clearly is the one whom the market rewards.
That is the economy most of us are familiar with and were trained to compete in. Enter AI.
The marginal cost of retrieving, synthesizing and producing knowledge is already near zero. The information economy’s primary asset has been commoditized. It’s still necessary, just no longer differentiating.
This is the fourth shift. And the instinct that most people have for how to respond to it is dead wrong.
The reflex is to double down. Learn more. Go get another credential. Get better at AI. That advice certainly feels right, but it’s solving the wrong problem. Think about a farmer in 1900 who responded to industrial agriculture by getting really good at plowing. He wasn’t wrong about plowing, but he’d misdiagnosed the problem and had chosen the wrong things to solve. The scarcity had already been relocated. All of his effort was being directed in exactly the wrong direction.
This time, the scarcity has moved to human capabilities that sit above information. Intentionality. Clarity. Discernment. Confidence. Adaptability. Creativity. Imagination. Agency. Think about them. None of these operate primarily on information. Rather, they determine what information means, what to do with it and whether a direction is worth pursuing at all. AI can process information at phenomenal speeds but it’s not great at orienting—yet.
Of those capacities, intent should come first. Without a clearly defined outcome, the machine will still produce something; it just won’t produce the right thing. And even then, there is a category of output it cannot produce at all.
AI finds the highest-probability path through everything that already exists. It is a regression toward the mean of human thought. It cannot originate a genuinely new idea because a new idea has no prior probability. It doesn’t exist yet in the universe of information the machine draws from. The AI machine is like the world’s most sophisticated polling machine. But no brand ever achieved distinction by asking the crowd what it wanted and complying.
That distinction comes from creativity—and creativity is more complicated than most discussions of it suggest.
Let’s take two things that might look the same but aren’t. The first is environment. Leaders who create conditions where creative risk becomes more acceptable are doing something genuinely important. The commission for a work of art is the condition that allows the work to exist. It creates the right environment. In the wrong environment, the creative impulse doesn’t disappear; it just never rises to become visible.
The second thing is sovereignty. In 1508, Pope Julius II commissioned the Sistine Chapel ceiling and then made Michelangelo’s working life as difficult as possible. Julius II was impatient, intrusive and relentless in his pressure. And yet, what the ceiling needed most wasn’t a patron who wrote a check and then got out of the way. It required a painter who could reach a state where the patron’s opinion couldn’t influence the act of painting. The Pope’s judgement was still there. It just couldn’t reach Michelangelo.
Both things are needed, and they operate in sequence. Environmental conditions make the first creative step possible. Sovereignty is what takes creative work past the first step and into its highest form of expression. One is the platform. The other is what you build on it. The leader’s job is the platform. The creative professional’s job is to not believe they need it. Courage becomes the mechanism. The freedom this courage produces is the condition that creativity actually requires.
Above creativity sits something even more valuable: decision-making.
Every other capacity on this list exists in service of a single moment: when someone has to choose. Intent without a decision is nothing more than a wish. Vision without a decision is merely observation. AI cannot produce a genuine decision because a genuine decision requires someone willing to be wrong, with skin in the game, who is willing to own what comes next. An AI recommendation that turns out to be wrong has no author to bear the risk; a human decision does.
The quality of that decision depends almost entirely on the inner state of the person making it. Calm produces clarity. Confidence produces commitment. Anxiety produces hedging. And hedging produces recommendations that feel safe and accomplish little.
The most valuable professional in the AI economy is not the one who knows the most or produces the most. It is the one who has developed genuine self-trust, the ability to be creative without requiring permission and the willingness to make a consequential call and own what happens next.
In my world, marketing, this is not an abstraction. Driven largely by the internet, the discipline has spent the past 20 years remaking itself as data science. The instinct now is to do the same thing one level up: Certify the team in AI, automate the content calendar, measure the efficiency gains. This is the farmer and the plow again: competing on production in an era where production is no longer the differentiator.
The constraint now is diagnosis. People don’t buy products; they buy affirmation, the resolution of something they already feel. Campaigns succeed because someone understood something true about what a specific group of people wanted to believe about themselves. That understanding is neither activated nor retrieved; it is arrived at. It requires curiosity, self-trust, creativity and the confidence to commit before data can confirm it.
The agencies that establish that diagnostic position will attain a different tier of value. The ones still competing on production are approaching a ceiling faster than they expect.
The next time that meeting happens, the most important question in the room won’t be how to get better at AI—it will be whether anyone around the table has done the hard work needed to give the right answer.


